Last updated: April 2026
There’s no major self storage facility inside North Tonawanda’s city limits. So when you search “storage units near North Tonawanda NY,” what you’re really looking at is a 4 to 6 mile drive into Wheatfield or Niagara Falls. Which one is closest depends on which side of NoTo you live on.
This guide names the actual nearest options, lists current monthly prices, and matches unit sizes to common North Tonawanda home setups. No aggregator fluff. No “Niagara Falls” listings that turn out to be 12 miles away near the tourist district. Just where to put your stuff when your garage on Oliver Street has gotten out of hand.
Where the Closest Storage Units to North Tonawanda Actually Are
The closest storage units to North Tonawanda, NY are at the Jeff’s Attic facility in Wheatfield (4.3 miles from NoTo center, starting at $170 per month) and the Niagara Falls location on Porter Road (about 6 miles, starting at $85 per month). North Tonawanda itself has no major self storage facility inside city limits, which is why most NoTo searches end up pointing across the border into Wheatfield.
For most residents, the Wheatfield location at 6870 Plaza Drive is the natural choice. It sits just north of NoTo on Niagara Falls Boulevard, has 24/7 access, and shares the same phone line as the rest of the Jeff’s Attic facilities. If you’re closer to the Niagara Falls side of town, the Porter Road location runs a little cheaper for the smallest units.
Closest Storage by North Tonawanda Neighborhood
Where you live in North Tonawanda actually changes which facility makes more sense. NoTo runs about 4 miles north to south, so a 5-minute drive from one end can be a 15-minute drive from the other.
Oliver Street and Payne Avenue Corridor
If you live along Oliver Street or Payne Avenue (the main north-south arteries through NoTo), the Wheatfield facility on Plaza Drive is your closest option. Take Niagara Falls Boulevard north, and you’re there in under 10 minutes most times of day.
Near Wheatfield Street and the DMV Area
The 500 block of Wheatfield Street, where the DMV sits, is right at the NoTo-Wheatfield border. From here, the Plaza Drive facility is the easy pick. You’re looking at a 6 to 8 minute drive depending on lights along Niagara Falls Blvd.
Riverside, Gratwick Park, and the Niagara River Side
If you’re on the river side of NoTo (Sweeney Street, Gratwick-Riverside Park, the marina area), both Wheatfield and the Niagara Falls Porter Road facility are in range. Porter Road runs a bit cheaper on smaller units. Wheatfield runs larger and gives you 24/7 vehicle access if you need to store a boat.
South End Near Tonawanda Border
If you’re south of Robinson Street, you’re closer to Tonawanda than Wheatfield. Some residents in this pocket end up at facilities on Kenmore Avenue. But for the price, Wheatfield is still competitive and more secure.
The Wheatfield site is closer but starts higher because the units are larger. Porter Road in Niagara Falls is the cheap small-unit pick for renters and apartment dwellers. Grand Island has the lowest base price in the entire system at $75 per month, but it’s the longest drive from NoTo.
A few honest notes most aggregator sites won’t tell you. National self-storage rates have been flat to slightly down over the past year, but Northeast markets have firmed up and prices can move when promotions end. Locking in a 30-day hold at the price you reserve protects you from a mid-move price bump. And the 10% military discount stacks on top of any current promotion, which is rare in this industry.
What Size Storage Unit You Need for a North Tonawanda Home
Most North Tonawanda homes are 2 to 3 bedroom single-family houses built between the late 1800s and the 1970s, with the bulk of housing dating to the 1940s through the 1960s. Detached garages and finished or semi-finished basements are common. That mix shapes what size unit you’ll need.
Jeff’s Attic offers 11 unit sizes ranging from 5×5 up to 20×30. Here’s how that maps to common NoTo storage situations.
5×5 to 5×10: Apartment cleanouts and seasonal storage
Holds boxes, off-season clothes, a small dresser, holiday decorations. Good for renters in a 1-bedroom apartment off Oliver Street or someone clearing out one room.
10×10: One-bedroom apartment or single room
Holds the contents of a one-bedroom apartment or one full room from a house. Mattress set, sofa, dresser, plus 30 to 40 boxes. The most-rented size in WNY storage.
10×15 to 10×20: Two-bedroom house contents
Holds 3 rooms of furniture: mattress sets, sofas, kitchen items, and boxes. Fits the typical contents of a 2-bedroom NoTo home if you’re between moves.
12×20 and 20×15: Full house move or vehicle plus belongings
Holds 4 to 5 rooms of furniture. If you’re moving out of a 3-bedroom on Payne Avenue and need to park the boat, this is your range.
20×20 to 20×30: Full house plus vehicle
Largest options. Full home contents, garage overflow, and a vehicle or boat under 25 feet.
If you’re not sure, our staff will help you pick the right size in person. Picking too small means you renting a second unit or playing Tetris with your stuff. Picking too big means paying for empty space.
Vehicle and Seasonal Storage for Boats and Snowmobiles
North Tonawanda has a strong boating community. Gratwick-Riverside Park, the Sweeney Street area, and the marinas along the Niagara River all push demand for off-season vehicle storage every fall. Snowmobiles and jet skis follow the same seasonal pattern in reverse.
Jeff’s Attic offers vehicle storage at all three WNY locations, including spaces for cars, boats, motorcycles, jet skis, and snowmobiles. The Wheatfield and Grand Island facilities both have larger drive-up units that fit boats and trailers up to 25 feet, plus standard vehicle bays for cars and trucks.
A few things NoTo boat owners should know before storing for winter. Fill the gas tank nearly to the top and add a marine-grade fuel stabilizer before storage. Filling the tank reduces condensation, and the stabilizer prevents ethanol-blended gas from breaking down and damaging the fuel system. Disconnect the battery. Cover the boat to keep dust off, but not with a tarp that traps moisture. New York boat registrations are valid for three years, so make sure yours doesn’t expire mid-storage. The DMV office at 500 Wheatfield Street in NoTo handles renewals.
If you’re storing a vehicle for more than 30 days, check whether your insurance company offers a comprehensive-only rate while it’s off the road. It can lower your premium significantly, sometimes by 50% or more during the storage months. Just remember to switch back to full coverage before driving again.
How to Reserve a Storage Unit Near North Tonawanda
Reserving a storage unit at Jeff’s Attic takes about 5 minutes online and locks in your size, price, and any active promotion for up to 30 days before move-in. No upfront payment required for the hold.
Here’s how it works:
- Pick the location closest to you. For most NoTo residents, that’s the Wheatfield location at 6870 Plaza Drive.
- Pick your size. Use the size guide above, or call (716) 773-2000 if you want our staff to help you pick.
- Reserve online. Your selected size, price, and current promotion are held for 30 days, no payment due until move-in.
- Move in on your schedule. All Jeff’s Attic facilities have 24/7 access. No appointments, no business-hours-only nonsense.
Active and retired military personnel get a 10% discount that stacks on top of any current promotion. There’s no other storage company in WNY that runs the discount this way. Bring your military ID at move-in.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are there any storage units actually inside North Tonawanda city limits?
There is no major self storage facility inside North Tonawanda proper. The closest options are in Wheatfield (4.3 miles from NoTo center) and Niagara Falls (about 6 miles). For practical purposes, “storage units near North Tonawanda” means storage in Wheatfield or Niagara Falls.
How much do storage units cost near North Tonawanda?
Jeff’s Attic prices near North Tonawanda start at $85 per month at the Niagara Falls location and $170 per month at the closer Wheatfield location. Prices vary by unit size, with 11 sizes available ranging from 5×5 up to 20×30.
Can I store a boat or snowmobile near North Tonawanda?
Yes. Jeff’s Attic offers vehicle storage at all three WNY locations, including boats, snowmobiles, jet skis, motorcycles, and cars. The Wheatfield and Grand Island facilities both have drive-up units that fit boats and trailers up to 25 feet.
How long does it take to drive from North Tonawanda to Wheatfield storage?
The drive from central North Tonawanda to the Jeff’s Attic Wheatfield facility at 6870 Plaza Drive is 4.3 miles, typically 8 to 12 minutes via Niagara Falls Boulevard depending on traffic and lights.
Storage Units Near North Tonawanda: The Bottom Line
The right storage unit near North Tonawanda is usually the Wheatfield Jeff’s Attic facility at 6870 Plaza Drive. It’s 4.3 miles up Niagara Falls Boulevard, has 24/7 access, and offers vehicle storage for boats and snowmobiles. If you’re after the cheapest small unit, the Porter Road location in Niagara Falls runs $85 per month and is about 6 miles south.
Either way, you can reserve online and hold the price for 30 days. Call (716) 773-2000 if you want our staff to walk you through the right size for your stuff.
Reserve your unit online or call us at (716) 773-2000.
About the Author
The Jeff’s Attic Team. Jeff’s Attic Secure Self Storage operates three facilities across Western New York and serves North Tonawanda, Wheatfield, Niagara Falls, Grand Island, and surrounding WNY communities. Our staff has helped thousands of WNY residents pick the right storage unit for their move, downsizing, or seasonal storage needs.